fix(uploads): make the drift guards fail for the reasons they claim

Deep-review round 3, targeted at the surfaces round 2's fix commit changed.
Five of the eight findings are the same shape: the guards written to stop
half-done sweeps were themselves half-done.

test_upload.py's display-field guard walked only `ast.Assign`, so the one
writer with an unbounded REQUEST HEADER behind it — `spool_upload`'s
`display_name=display_text(...)` keyword — was invisible to the guard meant
to protect it. It also stopped at `app/routes/`, missing the four writers in
`downloads/` that actually construct the row, and asserted `not offenders`,
which enforces nothing once a refactor moves the writers out of its view.
It now walks assignments AND keywords across `app/`, and holds exact set
equality against a registry of all twelve write sites with each one's value.

test_body_limit.py's release guard used `any(... ast.walk(fn))`, which
accepts a `release_read_connection` that runs AFTER the await it exists to
precede — satisfying the letter of the rule while pinning a connection for
exactly the transfer it was supposed to free. Position is checked now, and a
late release is its own, louder failure. The registry keyed sites by file
basename while scanning recursively, and `admin.py`, `discover.py` and
`playlists.py` each exist both at the top level and under `plex/` — the same
entry-collapse the registry was widened to close. Keyed by relative path now.
And all three guards recognised a body read only by the `capped_` naming
convention, so a route spelling `await request.body()` inline declared no
ceiling, released no connection, and was invisible to every one of them.

`release_read_connection`'s precondition claimed the caller "must have
NOTHING PENDING, and that is checked rather than described" while checking
only UNFLUSHED ORM work. Measured: after `add`+`flush` all three collections
are empty and the rollback loses the row, and Core DML never enters them at
all — both of them this codebase's canonical write shapes. It now also asks
the transaction directly via `pg_current_xact_id_if_assigned()`.

`errors.tooLarge` was reworded to "try a smaller file", but that key answers
every route's body cap: the issue composer's over-size JSON draft got advice
about a file it does not have. Back to payload-neutral; the file-specific
sentence keeps its own key.

The upload dialog's new danger border outranked `dragOver`, so a user
replacing an over-cap file got no sign the drop zone was live — and with a
file picked the label shows its name rather than "drop it here", so the
border was the only feedback left.

Four further findings were refuted 3/3 and are not fixed: `aria-invalid` on
the drop zone (measured in Chromium — the AX node does carry it on a native
button), a bidi-override spoof through `display_text` (the served filename
already strips those categories, and the proposed filter would have broken
every ZWJ emoji), and `capped_body` not draining (the screenshot route's edge
ceiling equals its own cap, so that refusal is unreachable, and the log sink
is sent by beacon with nobody reading the answer).
This commit is contained in:
2026-09-23 01:20:22 +02:00
parent 7c0647f87a
commit 321776480e
8 changed files with 283 additions and 64 deletions
+20 -1
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
from collections.abc import Iterator
from sqlalchemy import create_engine
from sqlalchemy import create_engine, text
from sqlalchemy.orm import DeclarativeBase, Session, sessionmaker
from app.config import settings
@@ -54,6 +54,16 @@ def release_read_connection(db: Session) -> None:
shared with every dependency that ran before, so a rollback here would silently discard a write
one of them staged — `service.enqueue` already learned that lesson the expensive way and uses a
SAVEPOINT for it. CLAUDE.md: a rule stated in a comment must also be enforced in code.
TWO checks, because the obvious one is blind to the shapes this codebase actually writes in.
`db.new`/`deleted`/`dirty` hold only UNFLUSHED unit-of-work: the moment a helper calls
`db.flush()` — CLAUDE.md's canonical split is "the handler commits; helpers flush" — the object
is persistent with no unflushed history and all three sets are empty again, and Core DML
(`db.execute(update(...))`) never enters them at all. Measured: after `add`+`flush` the sets are
empty, the old check passed, and the rollback lost the row. So the transaction is asked
directly. Postgres assigns a transaction id on the first WRITE and never for a read, so
`pg_current_xact_id_if_assigned()` is NULL for exactly the state this function is safe in — and
it sees a raw `text("UPDATE …")` too, which no session-level bookkeeping would.
"""
if db.new or db.deleted or db.dirty:
raise RuntimeError(
@@ -61,4 +71,13 @@ def release_read_connection(db: Session) -> None:
"staged a write, which ending the transaction would discard. Commit it first, or do "
"it after the await."
)
if (
db.in_transaction()
and db.execute(text("SELECT pg_current_xact_id_if_assigned()")).scalar() is not None
):
raise RuntimeError(
"release_read_connection() on a transaction that has already WRITTEN: something ahead "
"of this dependency flushed a row or ran an UPDATE/INSERT/DELETE, which ending the "
"transaction would discard. Commit it first, or do it after the await."
)
db.rollback()