E32 review round 1 (B5, B6).
- The autotag orphan cleanup reads every user's feed views. A view whose tag pick was not a list
("tags": 5) raised for everyone's job, True passed as tag id 1, and ~66k ids pushed the NOT IN
past psycopg's 65535 bind parameters. The views are now read defensively and the kept ids
filtered in Python; the saved-views route holds filters.tags to a list of at most 500 ids, on
create and on update.
- tags_by_category resolved any tag id, so another user's private tag landed in its real category
and the feed summary answered differently than for an id that does not exist, which told the
caller which foreign ids exist. It is owner-scoped now (pre-existing; S2's missing-tag branch
made the difference visible).
A saved view or the stored filter outlives its tag. feedquery dropped the unknown id, so the
view showed the whole feed under its old name. The id now lands in a MISSING_TAG_CATEGORY that
filters to nothing in the SQL and in feed_summary's mirror alike; the feed chip reads "Deleted
tag" (a placeholder while the tag list loads, the id if it failed). Channels' persisted tag
filter gets the same chip, first in the row so the +N overflow cannot fold it away.
Fixes from several multi-agent deep-review passes over the E8 feed-filtering &
channel-manager epic (S1-S4):
- feed_years buckets by UTC year to match the UTC-pinned year-filter bounds
- tag suggestions: examples ∩ subscribed (drop tagged-then-unsubscribed channels
from the profile denominator); exclude hidden channels as suggestion targets
- channel manager: restore ghost chips + surface an error toast on a failed tag accept
- year filter: debounce the search term so the per-year facet doesn't refetch per keystroke
- channel tags: aria-label the "+N" overflow pills
- extract useTagSuggestions hook; add backend + hook tests (profile boundaries, cap,
language exclusion, unsubscribed/hidden handling, UTC bucketing, bulk-accept)
Bump VERSION to 0.73.0 + release notes.
Add a Year filter to the feed rail: quick chips for recent years plus a
'More…' popover listing all years with per-year video counts, sortable by
year or count. Selecting a year narrows the feed to that whole calendar
year (a published_after/before range applied in the api layer) and is
mutually exclusive with the Upload-date control.
Backend: new /api/feed/years endpoint + feed_years() — one grouped query
that honours every filter EXCEPT the publish-date narrowing (dropped), so
the year list stays a live drill-down and switching years never zeroes the
others. FE keys the list on the date-stripped filters, so picking a year
re-queries the feed but not the list.
Wires year through FeedFilters, the filterParams/URL (?year) round-trip,
the active-filter chip row, and the panel layout. i18n HU+EN.
Tests: feed_years count query (date narrowing ignored, other filters
honoured); dateFilter year-clearing; urlState year round-trip.
Filter to channels you haven't personally tagged in the channel manager
(no user-owned ChannelTag; auto language/topic tags don't count):
- Feed: a "No tag" sentinel in the "Your tags" sidebar combobox (exclusive
with real tag picks) + a removable "Untagged" chip; new `untagged` bool
feed param / `notag` URL key, persisted + coerced on every filter path.
- Channel manager: a virtual "No tag" chip in the tag-chip row filters the
table to untagged channels (client-side, shared NO_TAG_SENTINEL).
Backend `untagged` is a plain channel-level narrowing, so feed_summary keeps
it applied in the base pass — the count/facet lockstep holds with no mirror.
Note: item E (per-tag counts) and item D (Any/All toggle) were already
shipped; S1 delivers only item B.
The re-review of the fix round surfaced 4 findings; fixing the coverage one
exposed that the C1 migration was ineffective:
- FeedFiltersProvider.loadAccountFilters: run coerceTagModes on the RAW stored
blob, not the object merged over DEFAULT_FILTERS. The merge injects
DEFAULT_TAG_MODES (all "or"), which coerceTagModes prefers over the legacy
scalar `tagMode` — so the migration never fired. Now a persisted legacy
tagMode:'and' actually migrates into tagModes.topic (proven by a new test).
- test_feed_views: the tag_mode_other=and case was vacuous (only chC carried
either "other" tag, so AND == OR). Give chA an "other" tag too so OR-other
{chA,chC} differs from AND-other {chC} — the conjunctive path now narrows.
- DateFilterSelect: reset the custom reveal in useLayoutEffect (not useEffect)
so the correction commits before paint — no one-frame "Custom range" flicker
on the trigger after an external clear.
- SavedViewsProvider: extract the sticky-view tie-break to a pure, tested
lib/savedViews.ts (preferSticky).
New tests: savedViews (preferSticky), FeedFiltersProvider.dom (legacy tagMode
migration on the localStorage/default-view seed).
- test_feed_views: extend _seed_tagged so a channel carries 2+ tags in a
non-topic category, and add language-AND / other-AND equivalence cases — the
per-category any/all generalization was only exercised for topic.
- tagModes.test: coerceTagModes migration (legacy global tagMode -> topic),
per-category preservation, invalid-value coercion, defaults.
- urlState.dom.test: per-category tag-mode URL round-trip + legacy ?tagmode=and
migration into the topic slot.
- Combobox.dom.test: the any/all match footer (hidden below 2 selections, reports
a mode change at 2+).
- chipOverflow.test: the all/some/count fit boundaries and the +N reservation.
The tag 'Match: Any/All' toggle was a single GLOBAL setting that only ever
affected topics, shown as its own row under the Topic widget. Make it
per-category — language, topic, and 'your tags' each get their own independent
any/all — and move it into each filter combobox's popover footer (like
SortControl's direction segment), reclaiming the standalone Match row.
Backend: the feed query already groups selected tags by category; replace the
single tag_mode with per-category tag_mode_language/topic/other params and apply
the conjunctive (HAVING all) branch per category. Mirrored across filtered_query,
feed_summary.passes(), and the /facets drill-down exclusion (kept in lockstep;
equivalence test updated to tag_mode_topic). No schema change.
Frontend: FeedFilters.tagMode -> tagModes {language,topic,other} (pure leaf
lib/api/tagModes with a coerceTagModes migration for the legacy global value);
serialized to the API and the shareable URL per category (legacy ?tagmode=and
still resolves into the topic slot); saved-view blobs migrate on read. Combobox
gains an optional matchMode/onMatchModeChange footer segment, shown once 2+
values are picked; the three tag comboboxes wire it to their category.
Verified: backend feed tests green (12, incl. the count/facets equivalence net);
live, the footer appears at 2+ selections, toggles aria-pressed, serializes
tagmode_topic=and to the URL, and the request carries tag_mode_topic=and (200).
374 vitest, tsc, ruff, eslint (0 err).
Review round on the E2 stack (S1-S5). No correctness bugs; the surviving
low/medium findings addressed:
- altitude (#1): extract the shared `tags_by_category` helper used by BOTH
filtered_query (SQL tag WHERE) and feed_summary (Python facet/count), removing
the category-grouping duplication, and add bidirectional "keep in lockstep —
equivalence-tested by test_feed_summary_matches_count_plus_facets" comments so
the SQL<->Python tag rule can't silently drift.
- test-coverage (#2): the /feed/summary equivalence test seeded only system tags,
leaving the `ChannelTag.user_id == user.id` visibility branch untested. Add a
user-owned Tag + link + two combos; the suite is now 346 (was 344) and the new
cases pass (feed_summary agrees with /feed/count + /facets on user-visible tags).
- dead-code (#3): annotate get_feed_count, get_facets, and the FE api.feedCount/
facets as "SUPERSEDED by /feed/summary — kept only as the equivalence oracle;
retire together" so the intentionally-retained surface reads as deliberate.
Not changed (confirmed no-op): the search channel-name resolve (#4) is
once-per-request on a 633-row table and a deliberate pre-resolve for PERF-12's
BitmapOr plan; the facet loop (#5) already computes passes() once per
(channel, category) with a distinct exclude each, so there is no recomputation.
Gate green: ruff + 346 pytest; frontend tsc/knip/prettier (FE change is a comment).
The FE fired /feed/count (1 pass) + /facets (3 passes) on every filter change =
4 full scans of the subscribed set. New /api/feed/summary does ONE grouped query
(the base filter with tags stripped, GROUP BY channel_id -> per-channel video
counts) and derives the total count + every tag's distinct-channel facet count in
Python on the ~few-hundred-row channel map, faithfully mirroring filtered_query's
channel-based tag logic + the /facets drill-down (own category dropped, unless a
conjunctive topic-AND). Returns {count, facets} — the same numbers the two old
endpoints returned.
FE: a single shared query (Feed reads .count, Sidebar reads .facets); same key +
filters, so React Query dedupes to ONE request. Invalidations repointed to
qk.feedSummary. The old /feed/count + /facets endpoints (and their now-unused FE
api/qk) are kept as the equivalence-test oracle + safety net; a later cleanup can
drop them.
New equivalence test (test_feed_views, 8 filter combos incl. cross-category,
disjunctive/conjunctive topic modes, search): /feed/summary count == /feed/count
and facets == /facets, byte-identical. Structural win: 2 requests / 4-6 queries
-> 1 request / 2-3 queries (the review measured 530 -> 144 ms). Gate green:
344 pytest, frontend tsc/eslint/knip/prettier/222 vitest.
PERF-12: the search ORed `unaccent(channels.title) ILIKE '%q%'` straight into
the per-video predicate, which forced a full scan + detoast of every
search_vector and a per-candidate channel fetch. Pre-resolve the matching
channel ids (a few-hundred-row scan) and match `Video.channel_id.in_(ids)`
instead, so the planner keeps the search_vector GIN as a BitmapOr branch
(alongside ix_videos_channel_pub_desc). Empty match -> false() collapses the OR.
PERF-16: show=watched|hidden|in_progress used an outer join + coalesce(status,
'new'), so the planner couldn't start from the user's small video_states set.
Those views only return rows that HAVE a state, so inner-join video_states and
filter the raw column (status is NOT NULL on a present row, so it's identical).
'unwatched'/'all' keep the outer join. Dropped the now-dead position_expr.
New regression tests (test_feed_views): search returns both text- and channel-
name matches; the four watch-state views return the exact expected sets.
Measured on the prod-sized localdev reseed (prod planner, 0067/0068 applied):
- search /feed/count q=magyar: 663,463 -> 19,206 buffers (1,406 -> 31 ms; OLD
seq-scan+detoast -> NEW BitmapOr GIN+channel index)
- search feed page: 2,908 -> 1,479 buffers (32.6 -> 1.4 ms)
- show=watched (user with 64 watched): 40,661 -> 264 buffers (~154x)
Gate green (336 pytest, incl. the 2 new equivalence tests).
peter