Deep-review round 5, over round 4's own fixes.
- `notifyActionError` preferred the server's `detail` over the caller's translated fallback, and
`reportFailure` deliberately leaves 403/404/429 to the caller — so for exactly those statuses the
dozen call sites round 4 converted started printing whatever English a route hand-wrote into an
otherwise Hungarian UI ("No user with that email.", "Not subscribed to this channel", "Unknown
job"). A STRUCTURED detail is still preferred: `req` has already run it through `localizeDetail`,
so it is both localized and more specific. A plain string is not.
- The other half of the same defect, on the backend: round 4's `get_or_404(what="channel")` sweep
reached exactly ONE of the five identical sites in channels.py and shipped the HU/EN string with
it, so the Block button said it in Hungarian and the four controls beside it in English. All five
are converted, and the subscription / share-recipient / scheduler-job 404s with them (two new
reasons in both locales).
- `PlexCollectionEditor`'s add/remove, take-over and delete were try/finally with no catch — in the
very file round 4 edited to give `createNew` one. 403 and 404 are the caller's to report, so the
tick simply never appeared and a CONFIRMED "delete collection" did nothing, silently.
- `UploadDialog` is the only `uploadReq` caller and kept an empty catch whose comment still claimed
the global error modal had it. It had not since `reportFailure` became shared: a proxy 502 raised
only the self-clearing connection notice and a 413/403/404 nothing at all, so the dialog snapped
back to its pre-upload state with no error named. The user's own Cancel stays silent — and since
a cancel and a network drop both carry status 0, that difference is now a named `isAborted`
rather than a string literal at each end.
Regression tests for each (5 vitest, 2 pytest, plus two existing assertions corrected), all
mutation-checked: 6 mutations, each red on the assertion it is named after. vitest 1007,
pytest 1127.
Round two of the review loop, on round one's own diff. Two of its findings were
regressions the fixes themselves introduced, which is exactly what the loop is for:
**A per-user refusal was writing onto a shared row.** MediaAssets are deduped across
users, and the generic failure handler puts the message on the asset — right for an
upstream failure, wrong for "your storage is full". Two users queuing the same video share
one asset, so the first user hitting their cap failed the second user's job with the first
one's private reason, telling someone with an empty library to free up space. The refusal
now raises `_OwnerRefused`, caught separately: the job fails, the asset goes back to
`pending` for whoever else holds it. Pinned by a test that drives `_download` directly —
the refusal happens before extraction, so nothing needs stubbing.
**The restore scripts restarted the app, undoing the restore.** `docker compose start`
re-runs the container command, and that runs `alembic upgrade head` — so on the rollback
path this documents as recommended (restore the dump, THEN pin the older tag) the newer
image immediately re-applied the migrations the restore had just undone, and on a FAILED
restore it put the app back on a half-restored schema. Both are the opposite of why the
stop was added. Nothing is restarted automatically now; the scripts say what to run and
when, and the docs' snippets say the same.
**Reverted rather than patched:** the OnboardingWizard toast (the wizard already renders
that failure inline, next to a Retry button — three recoveries for one failure), and
`useVerifyEntry`'s "each new link clears the other". The latter blanked the signed-out
card's only banner, where nothing renders the reset flag to replace it. The two states are
independent again; what changes is that `dismiss` peels ONE layer, which is what the
original finding was actually about.
Also: `Stats` uses the YouTube helper rather than the bare one, so the route's English 403
detail no longer beats the translated fallback under a Hungarian UI; `urlparse` guarded
alongside `.port` (an unclosed bracket raised just as late), the reason renamed `malformed`
since "bad port" misdescribes it; three docstrings narrowed to what the code actually does
(the worker's byte check is per-job, not an aggregate ledger, and not on the edit path;
the redirect residual leaks a reachability oracle, which the note had denied; the
invalidation helper does not cover suspend); the pasted Windows recipe wrapped so `throw`
can stop it; the bash one-liner's failure branch no longer exits 0; and the tests that were
missing for the round-one fixes — the account panel's error paths, the invalidation set,
and the shared-asset case above.
Gate green: vitest 685, pytest 950.
The deep review of the branch raised 47 findings, 18 of which survived adversarial
verification. Grouped by what they actually were:
**The size ceiling inverted at its boundary.** `remaining_bytes` clamped to 0 for a user
already at their storage cap, and `build_ydl_opts` reads 0 as "no limit" — so the one
user over quota was the only one downloading with no ceiling at all. `check_enqueue`
could not catch it: it ran while the job was queued and the user was still under the cap.
The arithmetic moves into `quota.remaining_bytes` (where every other max_bytes decision
lives, and where it can be tested), and the worker now fails the job outright rather than
proceeding unbounded — as a non-retryable `quota_exceeded`, since retrying cannot help
until space is freed.
**Silent failures in the new account panel.** All three actions went through `quiet: true`
endpoints, which suppress the global error dialog on the promise that the caller reports
inline — with no `onError`, that promise was broken and a refusal rendered as nothing. On
the broken-SMTP instance this panel exists for, an admin would read silence as "the mail
went out". The co-invalidation set and the email-off predicate move to `lib/adminUsers`,
shared with the pending-access queue, so the two copies of these mutations cannot drift
apart again — which is how half of this was lost in the first place.
**A rollback recipe that destroyed data without working.** `alembic downgrade -1` steps
back one migration, but a release routinely ships several (0.80.0 shipped four): it drops
the newest one's columns and leaves the schema at a revision the older image also cannot
resolve, i.e. the crash loop it was meant to escape, minus the data. The dump restore is
now the recommended path, and the alembic route asks the target version for its own head
revision instead of counting backwards.
Also: redirects named in the urlguard docstring beside the DNS-rebinding residual they
share a fix with (SEC-17); a malformed port refused as `bad_port` instead of escaping as
a 500; the pull cooldown extended to the sibling route spending the same QuotaAction;
restore stops the app before dropping its tables; the PowerShell cleanup can no longer
decide the script's verdict on 5.1, nor report the wrong exit code; the documented
one-liners hardened to match the scripts; the registry's retention window stated where
pinning is advertised; the two banners made mutually exclusive so neither can shadow the
other; `hover:bg-hover` (a utility this project never generated) replaced by the
`selectable` recipe; the clipboard helper reused; and the sync cooldown's copy swept to
the two callers that discarded it.
Verified: gate green (vitest 678, pytest 949), and the panel, the row hover and the reset
banner UAT'd on localdev.
SEC-12: the download box accepts an arbitrary http(s) URL and yt-dlp fetches
it from the WORKER, so any approved user could aim the server at the compose
network, the LAN or a cloud metadata endpoint — and read the result off
job.error, where "connection refused" vs "HTTP Error 401" vs "timed out" is a
port scanner. downloads/urlguard.py refuses a URL whose host resolves to a
loopback/private/link-local/reserved address, at enqueue AND again in the
worker (DNS can move in between, and the worker is where the socket opens).
A network-class failure on a `url` job now reports one fixed sentence instead
of the raw transport text; the error CODE is still classified from the
original, so the localized explanation is unchanged. DNS rebinding is
explicitly NOT closed — that needs the connection gated inside yt-dlp — and
the module says so rather than implying more than it does.
SEC-13: `noplaylist` only demotes a video-inside-a-playlist URL to that video,
so a URL that is purely a playlist or channel still expanded into every
entry — one enqueue, unbounded downloads. `playlist_items` pins it to one.
Size was unbounded too: `check_enqueue` compares the CURRENT footprint against
the cap, and a download's size is unknown until it lands, so one job could
overshoot by any amount; the owner's remaining budget is now handed to yt-dlp
as `max_filesize`, applied AFTER the adapter merge so no source adapter can
raise a limit the quota layer set. A join's cut-list is capped at 100: an
accurate join emits two filters per segment into one ffmpeg filter_complex.
SEC-14: the YouTube budget is instance-wide, so one user holding down a
manual sync spent the day for everyone. Per-user (not per-IP — the cost
belongs to the account) 3-per-10-minutes limiters on the two bulk pulls,
subscriptions and playlists, with separate budgets so one does not close the
other. The review also listed /rss, /backfill and /enrich; E3 deleted them,
and search stays unlimited on purpose — it is interactive, not a bulk pull.
Gate: pytest 896 -> 924 (none skipped), vitest 671.
Deep-review remediation on the frontend, all findings adversarially verified:
- LibraryPlayer picks audio vs video from the canonical media_kind (single source), not a
hardcoded container whitelist, so an uploaded audio file with an uncommon/absent container
renders in <audio> instead of a broken video box (legacy null media_kind keeps the heuristic).
- UploadDialog aborts the in-flight upload when the dialog is closed by X/ESC/backdrop/Back
(not only the footer Cancel); drag highlight uses an enter/leave depth counter to stop the
flicker; the progress bar gets a stable role=progressbar aria-label with the value on aria-valuenow.
- DownloadCenter's Shared tab renders honest loading/error states instead of a blank panel, and
the library/shared row-action gating moves to a single tested helper (lib/downloadActions).
Tests: downloadActions gating matrix, the uploadReq XHR path (abort/401/422-localize/onerror),
and the media_kind-driven audio/video branch.
i18n: downloads.upload.uploadProgress (HU + EN).
UploadDialog (drag-drop + native picker + optional display name) opened
from a new Upload button in the queue add-row. Uploads stream through a
new XHR helper (uploadReq in api/core) so the dialog shows real 0-100%
progress with a cancel — fetch/req can't report upload progress. The
upload lands as an already-done job; the S5b file-kind row gates it to
download+share. i18n HU/EN; upload cap/empty errors localize via the
shared structured-detail path.
Play a completed library item in-app: a Play button on Library rows (and
Shared rows with download access) opens a modal that streams the local file
into a native <video controls> (or <audio> for audio-only assets).
Rather than the YouTube IFrame PlayerModal or the Plex HLS PlexPlayer — both
bound to their own domain APIs and unable to point at a local file — this
reuses the shared Modal a11y shell (focus-trap, ESC, layer-stack, portal) and
the range-aware /api/downloads/{id}/file endpoint. S4a's universal-codec
guarantee (mp4/H.264/AAC + m4a/mp3) makes native playback always work, so seek,
volume, fullscreen and speed come for free with zero transcode.
D2-A: the library row's Share button becomes a single action — quickShareLink()
ensures a public link (minting on demand), copies it to the clipboard, and toasts
with an "Open in new tab" action. A copy failure still toasts (warning) with that
action so the link is never a dead end. Advanced controls (password/expiry/revoke/
user-ACL) stay in the existing ShareDialog, reached via a new "Manage sharing" row
button.
D1 (forward-only): CreateLinkIn.allow_download defaults to true, so a newly minted
link is downloadable by default. The default lives in the API, not a migration —
the download_links column default stays false, so no existing link flips. The
ShareDialog create-default is flipped to match.
Tests: TestCreateLinkDefault (default true; explicit false honored); 4 vitest cases
for quickShareLink (mint-vs-reuse, copy ok/fail, create failure). HU/EN parity.
The Download module's purpose is download -> share -> play in-browser, so the
output must play in EVERY browser (iOS/Safari/WebKit included). The only
universally-safe combo is mp4 + H.264 + AAC/MP3.
- formats.normalize() now CLAMPS every spec to that profile (container->mp4,
vcodec->None, audio_format opus->m4a) at the single point all paths flow
through (picker, stored profile, raw API) — not just by hiding UI options. A
source exposing no H.264 is still caught by the worker's browser-safe
re-encode, so playability is guaranteed end-to-end.
- build_ydl_opts drops the now-unreachable non-compat branches (+ _VCODEC_SORT).
- _SIG_VERSION 3->4 so assets cached under an old non-compat spec — or a stale
non-H.264 mp4 that slipped the v3 net (the HEVC Facebook dls) — re-derive.
- ProfileEditor drops the container/codec pickers and Opus; audio is M4A/MP3.
- i18n: remove the now-unused container/vcodec/any keys (HU+EN parity).
Each user stores their own login cookies (Netscape cookies.txt) for an
auth-walled download host (Facebook, Instagram, X, TikTok, Reddit) in
Settings; a download of an auth-walled link on that host is retried with
the acting user's cookie.
Two load-bearing security controls, both in downloads.credentials as the
single source of truth so enqueue and the worker can't drift:
- cache privacy: a cookie-authed download salts its MediaAsset format_sig
with the user id, so the authed asset is private and never cache-served
to another user. The worker attaches a cookie ONLY when the asset it is
downloading into IS that private, salted identity.
- host scope (SEC-12): a cookie is resolved only for a URL whose netloc
the credential owns (netloc-scoped _host_is); a look-alike/unrelated
host gets none.
cookies_enc is Fernet-encrypted at rest, only decrypted in-worker into a
0600 file under staging/.auth/ (survives the retry wipe + _produced_file
scan) and unlinked in finally. The blob is never returned by a route,
logged, audited, or written to a job's error/snapshot. cookiefile is set
after the adapter's extra merge so an adapter can't clobber it. Settings
UI is write-only (host + set/updated only, never echoed). New
download_credentials table + migration 0074; per-user routes; HU+EN i18n.
Tests: host-scope, cache-privacy (no cross-user serve), encrypt-at-rest,
write-only API, worker attach-gate; FE dom test for the write-only field.
5a — the public watch page rendered every asset in a <video>, but WebKit (all
iOS browsers) refuses to play an audio-only mp3 in <video>, so shared audio
links were broken on iPad while working on desktop Chromium. public_meta now
flags audio-only assets (codec present, no video stream) and WatchPage renders
a native <audio> in a padded surface card (no artwork exists for these).
5c — a login-walled Facebook post failed as a bare 'unknown', which offered a
misleading Retry. Classify closed-group / cookie-suggestion auth walls as
login_required and genuinely unsupported sites as a new unsupported_host class
(both non-retryable), and drop unknown from the modal's retryable set — an
unclassified failure is most often an unparsed auth wall. The queue row keeps
its own force-retry for real transients.
Failed downloads stored the raw yt-dlp/ffmpeg text and dumped it as a truncated red
one-liner in the queue. Classify the failure into a category (unavailable / login_required /
geo_blocked / format_unavailable / drm / postprocess / source_missing / network / unknown)
and surface it properly:
- backend: app/downloads/errors.classify maps the raw message to a category code; the worker
stores it in the new download_jobs.error_code (migration 0061) at both failure sites; resume
clears it; the serializer exposes it. Raw text kept as technical detail.
- frontend: the queue row shows a clean localized reason + a "details" link opening a modal
with the explanation, the raw text behind a disclosure, and a Retry only for transient
categories (network/postprocess/unknown).
- tests: classify() unit coverage over verbatim yt-dlp/ffmpeg message shapes.
- Always land on the Queue tab (drop the persisted last-tab) so new work/failures are the default view
- Show the download date (relative) on Library rows
- Share dialog opens with a default link already generated when none exists; all link controls stay available
- Thumbnail falls back to the self-hosted poster when a remote (i.ytimg/fbcdn) thumbnail 404s
- Add a clipboard-paste affordance to the add-URL box (explicit button + best-effort on focus)
Review follow-up on the share-link password UI:
- Removing a link's password makes it publicly watchable, a protection
downgrade; gate it behind a danger-confirm like the neighbouring Revoke,
spelling out that anyone with the URL can then watch without a password.
- When setting a first password the input reused the create-form "Password
(optional)" placeholder, but it's required here (Save stays disabled until
non-empty); use the "Set a password" wording instead.
C-3.7 made a password rotation invalidate outstanding grants, but ShareDialog
only let you set a password at link creation — there was no way to rotate or
clear it afterward, so the protection wasn't reachable. Add a lock control to
each existing link row: set / change / remove the password via the existing
update_link endpoint (which bumps password_version and revokes old grants).
Mini-epic "Downloads correctness & UX" (S1–S3), on top of the iOS-AV1 + 720p fixes.
S1 — naming & titles:
- ASCII-fold on-disk dir/file names AND the served (Content-Disposition) filename: no
spaces (underscore-joined), no accents (á→a, ő→o, ß→ss), pure ASCII — portable and free
of the `?` mojibake accented names show in non-UTF-8 tools. (Forward-only; existing files
clean up via re-download.)
- Strip a leading social engagement prefix ("1.6M views · 66K reactions | …") from titles.
S2 — universal browser playability (generalizes the iOS re-encode):
- ensure_browser_playable guarantees the stored file is H.264 + AAC/MP3 in mp4 — the only
combo every browser decodes. Re-encode just the offending stream(s) (video for AV1/VP9/HEVC,
audio for Opus/etc), or remux when only the container is wrong. Gated on the mp4 compat
profile (an explicit vcodec / non-mp4 custom profile opts out).
S3 — force re-download (preserves share links):
- POST /downloads/{job_id}/redownload keeps the job row so its public DownloadLink survives
and resolves to the freshly-downloaded file; deletes the old file and re-fetches under the
current rules. A failed re-download leaves the job in error (the intended broken-link case).
- Library "Re-download" action (icon + confirm), api method, hu/en strings.
Tests: naming/title-strip (test_naming), browser_transcode_flags matrix; existing
download_filename expectation updated for the underscore policy.
- player YB2: keepalive pagehide beacon (api.saveProgressBeacon) so the resume
position isn't lost on F5/close within 5s of the last checkpoint (mirrors Plex).
- player YB4: bound consecutive unplayable items in auto-advance so an
auto-advancing/loop=all queue can't spin over a run of dead videos.
- downloads B6 (client): localise structured quota/edit errors centrally in
api.req() via localizeDetail() + Intl.NumberFormat (fixes HU/DE + decimal sep);
+ 3-locale download error strings.
- channels FB1: focusChannelToken bump so re-clicking the same channel re-seeds
the search box; FB2: syncSubs invalidates feed/feed-count (set can change now).
- config CB2: reseed the ConfigPanel draft on a key-set dataVersion + explicit
post-save token, so a mid-edit refetch can't clobber an in-progress edit.
- config AB3 (UI): a blank allow_empty field stores "" instead of resetting.
- admin SB2/SC2: confirm + success toast on demo-whitelist remove and deny-invite
(+ trilingual strings); SC1: disable only the acted-on row (pendingId), not all;
SB3: pause the 1s scheduler countdown ticker while the tab is hidden.
- messages CT4: only invalidate conversations/unread when the incoming-message
count actually changed, not on every 20s poll; MB3 (client): react to the live
unread ping (onUnread → invalidate); MC3: extract e2ee installKey (setup/unlock);
CC2: hoist POLL_MS to messaging.ts; MB4: document the reload-scoped socket.
- Delete dead top-level downloads.rename.* i18n block (en/hu/de); the
metadata modal moved to downloads.edit.*. Keep downloads.actions.rename
(still used by ProfileEditor).
- Rename misnamed state renameJob/setRenameJob -> metaJob/setMetaJob in
DownloadCenter (it opens MetaEditModal, not a rename dialog).
- Extract the duplicated [downloads]/[download-index]/[download-usage]
invalidation trio into lib/downloads.ts invalidateDownloads(qc);
used by DownloadCenter and DownloadDialog.
Behavior-neutral. tsc green, knip shows no new unused export, JSON valid.
The edit (pencil) action now edits a download's full display metadata — title,
channel name, channel link and any number of extra reference URLs — instead of
just the name. The channel and links render as clickable links on the library
card, and the channel link is auto-filled from the source (yt-dlp channel_url)
when available. Shared watch pages resolve the same per-download overrides, so a
rename/channel/link edit is reflected on the public /watch page too, with every
link clickable.
Adds migration 0049 (media_assets.uploader_url; download_jobs.display_uploader,
display_uploader_url, extra_links) and generalizes the rename endpoint into a
metadata update with URL validation. EN/HU/DE strings included.
Every download now records the clean source page URL and shows it on the
Downloads page (open in a new tab, or copy to clipboard). The worker stores
yt-dlp's canonical webpage_url on the asset (migration 0043 adds
media_assets.source_webpage_url); the serializer prefers it and falls back to a
URL derived from source_kind+source_ref, so YouTube, external YouTube links and
external URLs (e.g. Facebook reels) all get a correct reference, and queued/older
rows work before the worker fills it. Edit clips return null (a clip's source is
the user's own earlier download, not a web page). i18n en/hu/de.
A shared-with-me item only had a download button. Add two actions (Share is intentionally NOT
offered — no chain re-sharing of someone else's file):
- Edit: the editor now accepts an accessible (owned OR shared) source, so editing a shared video
produces the editor's OWN clip in their library (counts against their quota, fully theirs
including share); the source file is only read. Route uses _accessible_job.
- Remove from my list: DELETE /api/downloads/shared/{job_id} deletes only the recipient's share
grant — the owner's job and physical file are untouched (per-user dismissal).
i18n en/hu/de. Verified in a real browser (edit a shared 70-min video → own 2:31 clip; remove
confirm shows 'won't delete the owner's file').
The admin System tab only listed users with an existing footprint, so a quota could be set only
after someone downloaded something. Add a 'Set a user's quota…' picker (over /api/admin/users,
excl. demo) beside the Per-user footprint heading that opens the quota editor for ANY user — the
quota GET/PUT endpoints already resolve defaults + create a row on demand, so no backend change.
Also show an empty-state line when no one has a footprint yet. i18n en/hu/de.
Rework the share dialog into two clear modes and add the public /watch player page:
- ShareDialog: (A) 'Share with a user' — autocomplete picker over registered users (was a blind
email box that 404'd on non-users); (B) 'Share a link' — create/list/copy/revoke public links
with allow-download toggle, optional expiry (1/7/30d), optional password; per-link view count.
- WatchPage: standalone login-free player at /watch/<token> (routed in main.tsx like /privacy),
self-contained mini-i18n (en/hu/de by browser language); password gate → unlock → play; shows a
Download button only when the link allows it.
- api: ShareLink/ShareRecipient types + link CRUD + recipients; share i18n (en/hu/de).
Verified end-to-end in a real browser: user picker, link create, public playback, stream-only vs
downloadable, password gate + unlock, no console errors.
VideoEditor modal on a finished Library download: HTML5 <video> scrubber, filmstrip timeline
(lazy server storyboard sprite) with draggable in/out handles, draggable/resizable crop overlay,
per-edit Precise (re-encode) vs Fast (stream-copy) cut toggle, split-into-N fan-out (N trim jobs),
optional clip name. Edited clips show a 'Clip' badge; 'editing' phase gets a % bar. New api
enqueueEdit/downloadStoryboard/storyboardImageUrl + EditSpec type; editor i18n (en/hu/de).
ffmpeg post-steps have no byte-progress, so instead of a silent 'Processing' the row now names
the current step (Merging / Extracting audio / Embedding thumbnail / Removing sponsors / Writing
metadata) with an indeterminate pulse. Byte-progress phases (video/audio) keep the % bar.
i18n en/hu/de.
The progress bar looked broken (95% -> 5% -> recount) because yt-dlp downloads the video and
audio streams separately (each 0->100%) then merges — with no indication of which step is
running. Now:
- worker labels the phase from the stream codecs (video / audio) and via a postprocessor hook
(merging / processing), so the user sees what's happening
- DownloadCenter shows the phase as the status and renders an indeterminate pulse (no bogus %)
during merge/processing; phase i18n en/hu/de
- yt-dlp retries (3) + fragment_retries (5) so transient network blips self-heal instead of
failing the job (seen once as a DNS 'No address associated with hostname' error)
Verified: phase transitions queued -> video -> processing -> done.